Quantcast

Barbis pledges to work on anger issues as Norwalk NAACP fights to oust him

At left, Norwalk Branch NAACP President Brenda Penn-Williams; at right, Norwalk Board of Education Chairman Mike Barbis.

NORWALK, Conn. – As the NAACP keeps the pressure on, demanding that Norwalk Board of Education Chairman Mike Barbis resign, Barbis has promised to “do the work… to ensure that my anger and frustration is handled in a more professional and reasonable way.”

Barbis released a statement Saturday reiterating both his apology for his June email, widely perceived as offensive, and his refusal to resign, emphasizing the many hours of work he has put into improving Norwalk Public Schools. 

Barbis, who ran unopposed, was re-elected to a four-year term on Nov. 5, three days after his profanity-riddled email was released by an anonymous source.

In Saturday’s statement, Barbis blamed allies of Mayor Harry Rilling, one of four recipients of the email, for launching “an absolute smear campaign” against him for supporting unsuccessful mayoral candidate Lisa Brinton.

Rilling, who has said Barbis has neither “the temperament or sensitivity” to be on the Board, called the accusation “ridiculous.”

Barbis’s statement comes as the Norwalk branch of the NAACP (National Association for the Advancement of Colored People) gears up for a showdown at Tuesday’s Board of Education meeting. The agenda includes the swearing in of new Board members and the election of a new chairman. The NAACP has offered transportation for those who support their call for Barbis’s resignation.

“The Board should act to censure as well as remove Barbis,” Norwalk NAACP President Brenda Penn-Williams and Connecticut NAACP President Scot Esdaile wrote in a letter released Wednesday, although there is no state law that would allow Board of Education members to remove Barbis.

This isn’t the first time the embattled BOE chairman has clashed with the city’s black leadership. In fact, at a meeting on Nov. 8, Rilling told NAACP members he declined to make the email public in June because of the effect it would have on his efforts to arrange a conciliatory meeting between Barbis and Penn-Williams. The hoped-for meeting never took place.

In the email, which Esdaile and Penn-Williams called “dastardly and alarming,” Barbis called South Norwalk Democrats “a*****” and “SCUM” and suggested a news headline of “Blacks f*** Latinos.”

Esdaile and Penn-Williams characterized the email as a BoE chairman “perpetuating racist thoughts” 65 years after the NAACP won a Supreme Court victory that declared a separate and unequal education was unconstitutional.

“The Barbis actions suggest that it is okay and acceptable to denigrate people of color,” they wrote. “It is inconceivable to think that Barbis can effectively serve as part an institution that benefits youth, especially those who are minorities, and employees who are not part of the dominant community.  Barbis has to go now!”

Barbis apologized for the email when it became public on Nov. 3 and on Saturday said he stands by that apology.

“Let me make this very clear, I am absolutely not racist,” he said. “What I was, on June 5, was frustrated and angry over what I believed to be unjust roadblocks set up for a new school in South Norwalk – something I have fought for and felt strongly would improve that neighborhood. Everything about my long record proves that I have been a relentless advocate for all of our town’s children. The root of the issue being discussed in that June email was my work trying to get a school built in an area where children are being bused around the city – when they deserve a school for their neighborhood like everyone else.”

State Rep. Travis Simms (D-140) and former State Rep. Bruce Morris, among others, have resisted the Board of Education’s effort to build a new South Norwalk school. Morris has sought more input from the community and Simms decries the loss of local parkland. Fears of gentrification are also in the mix.

Barbis is a Rowayton real estate agent. The planned new school is near the expensive waterfront properties in Wilson Point, adjacent to Rowayton. The site was chosen because city land could be used and a minimal investment put into acquiring property, consultants said in 2015.

Barbis on Saturday said he knows his email was wrong.

“I deeply apologize to anyone I offended with my words,” he said. “Because I am human, I am not perfect and made a mistake. None of that warrants the absolute smear campaign that has been launched against me – all being launched by allies of Mayor Rilling after I supported my friend, Lisa Brinton, for mayor.”

Barbis states that the email he sent went only to Rilling, Norwalk Chief of Staff Laoise King, Democratic Town Committee Chairman Ed Camacho and DTC Vice Chairwoman Eloisa Melendez.

“The email was forwarded to other people at the time it was received. I have no idea who those people forwarded it to or who those people might have forwarded it to,” King said on Nov. 3.

Mayor Harry Rilling, at the Nov. 7 emergency NAACP meeting in South Norwalk.

 

‘Democrats failing minorities’

Penn-Williams and Esdaile also criticize Camacho for saying nothing about the email. They call Rilling’s explanations “feeble.”

“The local Democratic leadership, Mayor and Town Committee Chairperson, is failing the Black and Latino communities in acquiescing by allowing or permitting Barbis to serve in any capacity in the City of Norwalk.  Barbis has to go now!” they wrote.

Camacho and Rilling did not respond to the comments.

 

‘Committed to serving Norwalk’s children’

It “strains credulity” that Barbis must be told to resign, Esdaile and Penn-Williams wrote. “However, such is the time that has come with racism eking out of the nation’s capital that bigots, nationalists, and white supremacists and people like Betsy DeVos and locally Mike Barbis feel that it is okay to berate and marginalize  people of color regardless of ethnicity.”

“I can promise two things,” Barbis said Saturday. “One, I will not resign from the Board of Education and will continue to represent those who elected me. Two, I will seek help and do the work I need to do to ensure that my anger and frustration is handled in a more professional and reasonable way going forward so that this doesn’t happen again.”

He said:

“In the 8 years I have been a volunteer and elected member of the Board of Education, I have fought tirelessly for all students to have a better education in Norwalk Public Schools – often at the expense of my own personal life and livelihood. I have done this because I feel so passionate about and committed to our town’s children and their rights to have the best education, in the safest and most up-to-date facilities we can provide them, and with the most advanced tools we can arm their teachers and administrators with.

“While on the Board of Education, I was Chairman of the Board for the last two years and Chair of the Facilities Committee for the last four years. I have served as Chairman of the Finance and Negotiations Committees, sat on the Curriculum Committee and currently sit on the Finance, Negotiations, Policy and Facilities Committees. I have helped hire two previous Superintendents, including Dr Steven Adamowski, whom many consider the most successful superintendent in Norwalk’s history. Everything from our accountability index to graduation rates to facilities has improved remarkably because of the work my BOE colleagues and I have done together – including the creation and implementation of our Strategic Operating Plan. I am extremely proud of this work.”

13 comments

John ONeill November 18, 2019 at 11:03 am

One piece of advice for NAACP for upcoming meeting: Please raise hell regarding lack of ELL funding from state. The Barbis situation may be the main headline, BUT the real story is reallocation of resources to support ELL Program in schools. THAT reallocation is hurting your kids more than you know. If NAACP does not take a stand on this you can’t take their leadership seriously.

Kathleen Montgomery November 18, 2019 at 12:31 pm

I highly recommend that Mr. Barbis take a leave from the BOE during the time he is working on anger issues.

Joe McNeil November 18, 2019 at 4:05 pm

Mr. Barbis fights for all kids of Norwalk and has residents support. This attack is just another example of entrenched interests trying legally to remove him from office.

David W. November 18, 2019 at 4:32 pm

I’d like to hear the story about who released this email and why it was released just days before the election. It doesn’t appear that there was much outrage when it was sent back in June.

Silence for for 5 months? As they say, silence is the voice of complicity.

Hopefully Nancy looks into a FOI request on that email and can track subsequent conversations in regards to its content.

…and John ONeill is spot on in regards to the NAACP support of ELL funds….although I doubt you hear them say a thing about it because they aren’t really supporting South Norwalks Latino soon-to-be majority.

Nora K King November 18, 2019 at 8:15 pm

Since when does Brenda Penn Williams defend the Latino community. This entire group has done nothing but fight to support the Latinos and a neighborhood school They should resign and be run out of town.

Tysen Canevari November 18, 2019 at 10:02 pm

Its great that the Democrats used this as a political ploy and then it comes back to haunt them. Now Harry and Bob want Barbis to quit. As a leader of Norwalk he found no issue with this email in June from such a high standing board of ed member? They called Lisa a racist? By Harry and company squashing this email I would say you are guilty by association!

Nancy Chapman November 18, 2019 at 10:28 pm

David W., Brenda Penn-Williams and the NAACP are not subject to the FOI Act. Citizens can demand emails from state or municipal agencies and people appointed or elected to commissions/boards, not emails from private organizations.
I asked her who sent it. She said it was sent anonymously.
Also, clarification for readers: This “David W.” is not David Westmoreland.

John ONeill November 18, 2019 at 11:48 pm

@Nora: Please clarify your post. The STATE ELL funding (or lack of it in Norwalk’s case) has Huge impact on programs effecting every student ESPECIALLY kids from low income demographics. It’s really a disgrace to think that Bob Duff is Senate leader and hasn’t brought any funding to Norwalk ELLers. African Americans should be irate. I am baffled by their apathy. I’m baffled by taxpayers apathy overall. We need to hold our elected leaders feet to the fire. If it can’t be done, WHY not? AND, WHO is keeping it from happening? If our legislators are not bringing home the bacon, they need to be voted out. It’s time for all of us to demand results not propaganda..

Bryan Meek November 19, 2019 at 8:31 am

Nancy, the email went to the Mayor and a member of his cabinet. You are quick to FOIA the BOE’s dinner plans. Why are you so reluctant to simply FOIA if the email was forwarded out of the mayor’s office and when? If it wasn’t then it clearly originated from the DTC, who are the only other recipients of the June email. The excuse you are using is lame.

David W. November 19, 2019 at 1:04 pm

Thanks for the reply Nancy. I understand that FOI doesn’t apply to private citizens but I’m referring to the public officials that received it, forwarded it, replied to it, or simple held onto it.

I’m not sticking up for Mr. Barbis behavior by any means but I do think that only half the story is being told. I’d really be interested to know how the public officials that received responded to it. It definitely is odd that it comes to public light 3 days before an election.

The public officials that sat on it actually should hold some of the blame. Maybe members of District E would have stepped up to find another candidate. We’ll never know since the email was kept under wraps for 5 months. As they say, silence is the voice of complicity.

(I’m not David Westmore)

Lisa H November 21, 2019 at 9:32 pm

Nancy, Are you going to FOIA where and/or if the email was sent out from the mayor’s office? Your readers would like to know. Thanks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>