Electric heat pumps use much less energy than furnaces, and can cool houses too – here’s how they work

Heating or cooling? I do both. (FanFan61618/Flickr, CC BY-SA)

To help curb climate change, President Biden has set a goal of lowering U.S. greenhouse gas emissions 50%-52% below 2005 levels by 2030. Meeting this target will require rapidly converting as many fossil fuel-powered activities to electricity as possible, and then generating that electricity from low-carbon and carbon-free sources such as wind, solar, hydropower and nuclear energy.

The buildings that people live and work in consume substantial amounts of energy. In 2019, commercial and residential buildings accounted for more than one-seventh of U.S. greenhouse gas emissions. New heating and cooling strategies are an important piece of the puzzle.

Fortunately, there’s an existing technology that can do this: electric heat pumps that are three to four times more efficient than furnaces. These devices heat homes in winter and cool them in summer by moving heat in and out of buildings, rather than by burning fossil fuel.

As a scientist focusing on renewable and clean energy, I study energy use in housing and what slowing climate change means for industrialized and developing countries. I see powering buildings with clean, renewable electricity as an essential strategy that also will save consumers money.

Heat pumps draw in air from the outside and use the difference in temperature between indoor and outdoor air to heat buildings. Many also provide cooling, using nearly the same mechanism.

Heat pumps work by moving heat, not air

Most heating systems in the U.S. use forced-air furnaces that run on natural gas or electricity, or in some cases heating oil. To heat the building, the systems burn fuel or use electricity to heat up air, and then blow the warm air through ducts into individual rooms.

A heat pump works more like a refrigerator, which extracts energy from the air inside the fridge and dumps that energy into the room, leaving the inside cooler. To heat a building, a heat pump extracts energy from outdoor air or from the ground and converts it to heat for the house.

Here’s how it works: Extremely cold fluid circulates through coils of tubing in the heat pump’s outdoor unit. That fluid absorbs energy in the form of heat from the surrounding air, which is warmer than the fluid. The fluid vaporizes and then circulates into a compressor. Compressing any gas heats it up, so this process generates heat. Then the vapor moves through coils of tubing in the indoor unit of the heat pump, heating the building.

In summer, the heat pump runs in reverse and takes energy from the room and moves that heat outdoors, even though it’s hotter outside – basically, functioning like a bigger version of a refrigerator.

More efficient than furnaces

Heat pumps require some electricity to run, but it’s a relatively small amount. Modern heat pump systems can transfer three or four times more thermal energy in the form of heat than they consume in electrical energy to do this work – and that the homeowner pays for.

In contrast, converting energy from one form to another, as conventional heating systems do, always wastes some of it. That’s true for burning oil or gas to heat air in a furnace, or using electric heaters to heat air – although in that case, the waste occurs when the electricity is generated. About two-thirds of the energy used to produce electricity at a power plant is lost in the process.

Retrofitting residences and commercial buildings with heat pumps increases heating efficiency. When combined with a switch from fossil fuels to renewables, it further lowers energy use and carbon emissions.

Going electric

Growing restrictions on fossil fuel use and proactive policies are driving sales of heat pumps in the U.S. and internationally. Heat pumps are currently used in 5% of heating systems worldwide, a share that will need to increase to one-third by 2030 and much higher after to reach net-zero emissions by 2050.

In warmer areas with relatively low heating demands, heat pumps are cheaper to run than furnaces. Tax credits, utility rebates or other subsidies may also provide incentives to help with up-front costs, including federal incentives reinstated by the Biden administration.

In extremely cold climates, these systems have an extra internal heater to help out. This unit is not as efficient, and can significantly run up electric bills. People who live in cold locations may want to consider geothermal heat pumps as an alternative.

Infographic advertising rebates for installing geothermal heat pumps in New Jersey.
Geothermal heat pumps may be a better option than air-source versions in colder climates. (NJDEP)

These systems leverage the fact that ground temperature is warmer than the air in winter. Geothermal systems collect warmth from the earth and use the same fluid and compressor technology as air source heat pumps to transfer heat into buildings. They cost more, since installing them involves excavation to bury tubing below ground, but they also reduce electricity use.

New, smaller mini-split” heat pump systems work well in all but the coldest climates. Instead of requiring ducts to move air through buildings, these systems connect to wall-mounted units that heat or cool individual rooms. They are easy to install and can be selectively used in individual apartments, which makes retrofitting large buildings easier.

Even with the best heating and cooling systems, installing proper insulation and sealing building leaks are key to reducing energy use. You can also experiment with your thermostat to see how little you can heat or cool your home while keeping everyone in it comfortable.

Mini split heat pump indoor unit mounted over a fireplace.
A new mini split heat pump system. (Robert Brecha, CC BY-ND)

For help figuring out whether a heat pump can work for you, one good source of information is your electricity provider. Many utilities offer home energy audits that can identify cost-effective ways to make your home more energy-efficient. Other good sources include the U.S. Department of Energy and the American Council for an Energy Efficient Economy. As the push to electrify society gains speed, heat pumps are ready to play a central role.

[The Conversation’s science, health and technology editors pick their favorite stories. Weekly on Wednesdays.]The Conversation

Robert Brecha, Professor of Sustainability, University of Dayton

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.


9 responses to “Electric heat pumps use much less energy than furnaces, and can cool houses too – here’s how they work”

  1. David T McCarthy

    These work in areas that don’t get very cold. In Connecticut, the heat pump relies on electric resistance, which is the most inefficient form of heating. To be fair, this is reflected in the paragraph marked “Going Electric” but it is even worse than described. I had one in PA and I moved rather than pay that bill again.

  2. Jason

    David- The heat pump technology has changed rapidly in the last few years. They are now efficient down to zero before they need any supplemental coil heat. The efficiency achieved by these new generation heat pumps today makes them a cheaper form of heating and cooling here in CT than oil or gas.

  3. Niz

    What about Geothermal systems?

  4. George

    In fixing my research into the new heat pumps I find the even with the extra heat coils the heat pumps use more energy. They are forced to run longer and harder once it is 25 to 30 degrees outside. Thinking of it as driving a 4 cylinder engine up a mountain vs. an 8 cylinder engine. Yeah, you’ll get there but the stain on the engine is much greater.

    I’d put two heating system. A heat pump which will be turned off once winter hits and a gas system for the winter. Both backed up with a gas generator.

  5. Frank Wainwright

    Had we continued to develop nuclear power back in the 70s we wouldnt be talking about any of this stuff today. Following “the science”?

  6. David Osler

    Pumps are a great technology but this article misses much of their capabilities as well as skating over their drawbacks for a hot water system an electric heat pump connected to a hot water tank is great for replacing electric hot water heater at the same time using it to replace oil or gas heating it is lousy at best as for cooling technology it really depends on where you’re getting your cold energy source from and then turning around and dumping the heat if you have a good temperature differential that works in your favor such as a pond the ocean that’s great in the summer however for household heating you’re much better off with geothermal which also does a remarkably good job at cooling but for the form of air conditioning in most situations and heating is most situations until our electric grid gets much more efficient this is not a practical answer for anything beyond your hot water tank in Connecticut’s climate

  7. Bryan Meek

    Cool. We can have brownouts in the winter now too.

  8. Vic Hardy

    I have a combo A/C and heatpump I bought 5 years ago. It’s a Trane system and works well, however even here in Georgia some of the winter nights get into the 30’s, even 20’s. The heat pump kicks on and runs for hours and I have to intervene and turn it to the NG mode.

    I’ve also heard that there’s been some improvements in heat pump technology but my guess is that it’s expensive and still is a long way from how fast a gas system will heat.

  9. Danny Mc

    There have been many articles recently touting heat pumps in lieu of furnaces. In the past year, I began renting a home in NJ with a heat pump. It ran nearly constantly for long periods this winter. My electric bill was so incredibly high I assumed something must be wrong with the unit. (About 30% – 50% greater than summer peak.) An HVAC tech inspected it a found it was working as intended.

    My point is, the utility costs associated with using a heat pump in the northeast or midwest is being minimized in current media.

Leave a Reply

Recent Comments